Join the movement
Shivani Gopal

Shivani Gopal

May 20, 2022
| Mentoring

How career coaches and mentors can get results for their mentees

Being a coach and mentor is one of the most rewarding jobs on the planet. You get to invest your expertise into people and watch them grow from strength to strength.

Though, it can be really challenging because you’re working with people’s hopes and dreams — and sometimes they expect you to have all the answers. When in reality, your job is to help them find the answers from a  combination of mentee and mentor experiences.

“The ‘sweet spot’ is somewhere in between — having clarity about general direction and what you want from a job in terms of how it builds on your strengths, how it allows you to grow and how it aligns with your own values and sense of life purpose.”

Coaching is a great way to help others expand their potential. Recently, the value of mentorship and coaching has become a staple for career driven people because it offers them access to proven and real world strategies that they can use to achieve their own success — the stuff that you can’t get from courses and academia!

However, coaches have immense responsibility because they’re dealing directly with the hopes and dreams of others. All successful coaches know what an amazing experience it is to see someone going from strength to strength because of their advice, but it can also be high pressure and frustrating when you have a client who is just not seeing any results.

Here’s how you can best help your mentees through your coaching. 

What is a coach’s job?

The term coach is borrowed by businesses everywhere. It comes from the sports field where players need to work together under one cohesive vision.

The value of a coach is in their expert opinion and objective perspective which allows ‘players’ to get an unbiased view of their skills. A coach builds on their team’s strengths whilst fixing their weakness. They come up with tailored strategies and tactics that are based on knowledge and expertise to give their team the best chance possible at achieving their collective goal.

The job of a coach is simple: to get the best out of people.

Nurturing clarity

As a career coach or mentor, you’ll likely be working with individuals, one-on-one. You’ll notice that your mentees will have tension and stress around not knowing what to do next, or being unclear about what their goals are.

A coach needs to foster clear thinking in their mentees by uncovering their hopes, dreams, goals and purpose.

A good way to help mentees is to use a system that helps them identify, evaluate and weigh opportunities so that they can make an educated choice around what to do next. This system will help them scaffold their choices in categories of immediate, short-term and long-term goals.

Stephen Covey’s famous matrix is a great tool to reference for this:


Helping mentees find and maintain clarity is really important.

“The ‘sweet spot’ is somewhere in between — having clarity about general direction and what you want from a job in terms of how it builds on your strengths, how it allows you to grow and how it aligns with your own values and sense of life purpose.” – Steven Cutterback

Promoting decision making

A great coach and mentor works their way out of their mentee’s life. They know that every coaching relationship must have a clear beginning and end.

This means that you want to teach and prepare your mentees to take ownership of their life and not to become too reliant on you — because, at the end of the day, it’s their life, and they’re in the driver’s seat.

This means that building confidence and promoting decision making is a must. As a coach, be careful not to steer your mentees toward any specific choice, you have to provide knowledge as best as you can, but you can’t take their power away by pushing them toward something, even if you think it’s for the best— they have to come to their own decisions.

Use a simple strategy to help your mentees take ownership of their own choices. The faithful ‘pros and cons’ table is perfect for this.

Practice this

Write the outcome of the decision on the top of the page. Then 1_GyuFjCATxWKD79AJDxewqQdivide the page in half. On the left write ‘Pros’ and on the right, write ‘Cons’.

Have your mentees make a separate table for each outcome that they can think of based on a specific decision. Once they’ve done this, it will be clear to them which choice to make. And, best of all, you’ve helped them to build confidence and keep their autonomy in making their own decisions .

You’ve just helped them take ownership and be confident in their vision of how they want their lives to be.

Defining growth and progress

We need clear metrics to ensure that our mentees are growing. But, the mentee has to be responsible for defining these metrics.

As a coach and mentor, your job is to make sure that they define metrics for both ‘integral’ and ‘reputational’ aspects of their life.

Integral aspects are how mentees see themselves and reputational aspects are how others see them.

The Art of Mentoring defines the common integral and reputational aspects that most mentees aim for.

Common integral aspects:

  • Income

  • The number or range of projects they are involved in

  • Rank on the leadership hierarchy

  • Job satisfaction

  • Rate of learning new things


Common Reputational aspects

  • Experience in high developmental roles

  • Involved in high-profile team projects

  • Being perceived as a “talent to keep an eye on”

“The analogy for modern careers is not a train on the tracks to a terminus, but a sailing boat setting out on a voyage of discovery. We are all at whim of the winds and tides, tacking and adjusting the sails continuously to take the greatest advantage of them. The role of the mentor in relation to career advice is to raise the mentee’s awareness and help them make better choices.”— David Cutterback 

Your remarkable life starts here.

Join the Inner Circle today.

Keep up to date with our important articles and research.

  • Free to join
  • Access FB Group
  • Weekly digests

Related articles

Womens Advocacy

Founder's Weekly 20th May 2022: Domestic violence leave doubled + Barbie gets a diversity makeover

Read this post
Womens Advocacy

Founder's Weekly 13th May 2022: How fixing the pay gap fixes the skills shortage + a fashion debut that really is inclusive

Read this post
Featured Article, Wellbeing

Voices of Ukraine: Kateryna and Olena’s Story

Read this post